Protocols, Truth and Convention

¡ Studien zur Ãļsterreichischen Philosophie āļ´āˇœāļ­ 19 ¡ Rodopi
āļ‰-āļ´āˇœāļ­
147
āļ´āˇ’āļ§āˇ”
āˇƒāˇ”āļ¯āˇ”āˇƒāˇ”āļšāļ¸āˇŠ āļŊāļļāļē⎒

āļ¸āˇ™āļ¸ āļ‰-āļ´āˇœāļ­ āļœāˇāļą

The continuing philosophical interest in the famous 'Protocol Sentence Debate' in the Vienna Circle of Logical Positivists is, to a large measure, due to the focus on the epistemological issues in the dispute, and the neglect of differences among the leading players in their philosophical views of logic and language. In Protocols, Truth and Convention, the current understanding of the debate is advanced by developing the contemporaneous views of logic and language held by the principal disputants. Rudolf Carnap and Moritz Schlick. It is argued - largely on the basis of unpublished manuscripts and correspondence - that, despite apparent differences in their respective conceptions of language, there are nonetheless striking similarities, particularly with respect to the conventionality of language. Nonetheless, one key issue - concerning the syntacticism inherent in Carnap's early Thirties' philosophy - separates the two viewpoints in the clash over protocols. Finally, it is argued that Carnap's syntacticism is untenable, a conclusion that Carnap himself finally reached in the closing exchanges of the protocol sentence controversy.
The continuing philosophical interest in the famous 'Protocol Sentence Debate' in the Vienna Circle of Logical Positivists is, to a large measure, due to the focus on the epistemological issues in the dispute, and the neglect of differences among the leading players in their philosophical views o...

āļ­āˇ€ ⎃⎜āļēāˇ āļœāļąāˇŠāļą

āļ¸āˇ™āļ¸ āļ‰-āļ´āˇœāļ­ āļ…āļœāļēāļąāˇŠāļą

āļ”āļļ āˇƒāˇ’āļ­āļą āļ¯āˇ™āļē āļ…āļ´āļ§ āļšāˇ’āļēāļąāˇŠāļą.

āļšāˇ’āļē⎀⎓āļ¸āˇš āļ­āˇœāļģāļ­āˇ”āļģ⎔

⎃⎊āļ¸āˇāļģ⎊āļ§āˇŠ āļ¯āˇ”āļģāļšāļŽāļą āˇƒāˇ„ āļ§āˇāļļ⎊āļŊāļ§āˇŠ
Android āˇƒāˇ„ iPad/iPhone ⎃āļŗāˇ„āˇ Google Play āļ´āˇœāļ­āˇŠ āļē⎙āļ¯āˇ”āļ¸ āˇƒāˇŠāļŽāˇāļ´āļąāļē āļšāļģāļąāˇŠāļą. āļ‘āļē āļ”āļļ⎚ āļœāˇ’āļĢ⎔āļ¸ āˇƒāļ¸āļŸ āˇƒāˇŠāˇ€āļēāļ‚āļšāˇŠâ€āļģ⎓āļē⎀ ⎃āļ¸āļ¸āˇ”⎄⎔āļģ⎊āļ­ āļšāļģāļą āļ…āļ­āļģ āļ”āļļāļ§ āļ•āļąāˇ‘āļ¸ āļ­āˇāļąāļš āˇƒāˇ’āļ§ āˇƒāļļ⎐āļŗāˇ’⎀ āˇ„āˇ āļąāˇœāļļ⎐āļŗāˇ’⎀ āļšāˇ’āļē⎀⎓āļ¸āļ§ āļ‰āļŠ āˇƒāļŊ⎃āļē⎒.
āļŊ⎐āļ´āˇŠāļ§āˇœāļ´āˇŠ āˇƒāˇ„ āļ´āļģ⎒āļœāļĢāļš
āļ”āļļāļ§ āļ”āļļ⎚ āļ´āļģ⎒āļœāļĢāļšāļē⎚ ⎀⎙āļļ⎊ āļļāˇŠâ€āļģāˇ€āˇŠāˇƒāļģāļē āļˇāˇāˇ€āˇ’āļ­āļē⎙āļąāˇŠ Google Play āļ¸āļ­ āļ¸āˇ’āļŊāļ¯āˇ“ āļœāļ­āˇŠ āˇāˇŠâ€āļģāˇ€āˇŠâ€āļēāļ´āˇœāļ­āˇŠāˇ€āļŊāļ§ āˇƒāˇ€āļąāˇŠ āļ¯āˇ’āļē ⎄⎐āļš.
eReaders āˇƒāˇ„ ⎀⎙āļąāļ­āˇŠ āļ‹āļ´āˇāļ‚āļœ
Kobo eReaders ⎀⎐āļąāˇ’ e-ink āļ‹āļ´āˇāļ‚āļœ āļ´āˇ’⎅⎒āļļāļŗ āļšāˇ’āļē⎀⎓āļ¸āļ§, āļ”āļļ āˇ€āˇ’āˇƒāˇ’āļąāˇŠ āļœāˇœāļąāˇ”⎀āļšāˇŠ āļļāˇāļœāˇ™āļą āļ”āļļ⎚ āļ‹āļ´āˇāļ‚āļœāļēāļ§ āļ‘āļē āļ¸āˇāļģ⎔ āļšāˇ’āļģ⎓āļ¸ āˇƒāˇ’āļ¯āˇ” āļšāˇ… āļē⎔āļ­āˇ” āˇ€āˇš. āļ†āļ°āˇāļģāļšāļģ⎔ āļ‰-āļšāˇ’āļē⎀āļąāļēāļ§ āļœāˇœāļąāˇ” āļ¸āˇāļģ⎔ āļšāˇ’āļģ⎓āļ¸āļ§ āˇ€āˇ’āˇƒāˇŠāļ­āļģāˇāļ­āˇŠāļ¸āļš āļ‹āļ¯āˇ€āˇ” āļ¸āļ°āˇŠâ€āļē⎃⎊āļŽāˇāļą āļ‹āļ´āļ¯āˇ™āˇƒāˇŠ āļ…āļąāˇ”āļœāļ¸āļąāļē āļšāļģāļąāˇŠāļą.

āļ¸āˇāļŊāˇāˇ€ āļ…āļ›āļĢ⎊āļŠāˇ€ āļšāˇ’āļē⎀āļąāˇŠāļą

Thomas Oberdan āˇ€āˇ’āˇƒāˇ’āļąāˇŠ āļ­āˇ€āļ­āˇŠ

⎃āļ¸āˇāļą āļ‰-āļ´āˇœāļ­āˇŠ